Immigration Appeals Attorney: Challenging a Denial

Home / Services / Appeals

If your immigration case or application is denied, you’re usually given an option to appeal — but which appeal body and which form you use depends entirely on what kind of decision you’re challenging. Filing the wrong form can result in automatic rejection of an otherwise valid appeal. Santana Residency Law helps clients throughout Miami and across the U.S. identify the correct appeal path and build a strong case.

This page is for general information only and is not legal advice. Call Santana Residency Law as soon as possible after a denial. Appeal deadlines are short and generally cannot be extended.

Which Appeal Body Handles Your Case? This Is the First Question

Family-based petition denials

Most other USCIS petition denials

Immigration judge decisions

Using the wrong form is one of the most common and most costly mistakes in this area. A denied I-130 marriage-based petition, for example, must be appealed to the BIA on Form EOIR-29; filing Form I-290B for that same denial will be rejected outright. Confirming the correct path before filing is essential.

Notice of Intent to Deny or Revoke, and Marriage-Fraud Accusations

When filing for residency through marriage, USCIS may issue a Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID) based on a preliminary —and sometimes incorrect — determination that the marriage was entered into solely to obtain immigration benefits. A NOID is not a final decision; it’s an opportunity to respond with additional evidence before USCIS decides.

This is one of the highest-stakes situations in immigration law. If USCIS ultimately denies the petition and makes a finding under INA §204(c) — the marriage-fraud bar — the consequence isn’t limited to that one petition. A §204(c) finding creates a permanent bar, with no waiver available, blocking any future immigrant petition filed on that person’s behalf, by any petitioner, for the rest of their life. Because of this, a NOID response addressing a marriage-fraud concern deserves the most thorough, well-documented response possible — this is not a situation to respond to lightly or without legal guidance.

If a §204(c) finding is made, the response depends on the stage:

At the NOID stage: respond with detailed evidence addressing the specific concerns raised, before any final decision is made — this is the strongest opportunity to prevent the finding entirely.
After a final denial: a family-based petition with a §204(c) finding is appealed to the BIA on Form EOIR-29, not Form I-290B. The Board reviews the administrative record built during the case, so evidence not submitted earlier may not be considered on appeal — reinforcing why the NOID response stage matters so much.

Appealing a Denial from an Immigration Judge (BIA)

If you’ve lost your case before an immigration judge, you’re generally eligible to appeal to the Board of Immigration
Appeals (BIA). You must file a Notice of Appeal within 30 days of the decision, and then supplement it with a legal brief. The BIA sends a briefing schedule and hearing transcripts to support the preparation of your legal arguments.

Appealing a USCIS Decision (AAO or I-290B)

For most USCIS petition denials outside the family-based category, Form I-290B is used to request review — either as an appeal to the AAO or, in some circumstances, as a motion to reopen or reconsider at the local USCIS office that issued the decision. Deadlines are typically 30 days from the decision (33 days if mailed), and missing them generally forfeits the right to appeal.

Do you have questions about your immigration case?

(305) 916-4800

Our team is here to listen, answer your questions, and help you understand your next steps.

HAVE QUESTIONS?

How Santana Residency Law Can Help

We help clients quickly identify which appeal path applies to their specific denial, respond to NOIDs — especially those involving marriage-fraud allegations — with the depth of evidence these cases demand, and prepare complete, well-supported appeals to the BIA or AAO.

Do all immigration appeals go to the same place?

No. Family-based petition denials, including marriage-based I-130 cases, go to the Board of Immigration Appeals on Form EOIR-29. Most other USCIS petition denials go to the Administrative Appeals Office on Form I-290B. Immigration judge decisions in removal proceedings are also appealed to the BIA, using a separate notice of appeal. Using the wrong form for the wrong decision type typically results in rejection.

What happens if USCIS accuses my marriage of being fraudulent?

USCIS will typically issue a Notice of Intent to Deny explaining its concerns before making a final decision. This is the best opportunity to respond with detailed evidence — personal statements, financial records, photos, and other proof of a bona fide marriage — before a final denial is issued.

Is a marriage-fraud finding permanent?

Yes. A finding under INA §204(c) creates a permanent bar with no available waiver, preventing any future immigrant petition from being approved on that person's behalf, regardless of who files it or when. This is why responding thoroughly at the NOID stage is so important.

How long do I have to appeal a denial?

It depends on the decision type. An appeal from an immigration judge to the BIA is generally due within 30 days. A USCIS decision appealed via Form I-290B is generally due within 30 days of service, or 33 days if mailed. Deadlines are strictly enforced.

Can new evidence be submitted during an appeal?

Generally, appellate bodies like the BIA and AAO review the existing administrative record rather than accepting significant new evidence — which is why building a complete record at the NOID response or initial-filing stage is so important. New evidence discovered after a denial may instead support a motion to reopen rather than a straightforward appeal.

Let’s talk about your immigration case

Our team can help you understand your options and the next steps based on your situation.